Interesting times for operations leaders
Whether your industry has been relatively stable or has rapidly shifting trends, you've noticed that it's getting harder to carry out a strategy. Digital technology is changing the way we all perceive value. Customer priorities are moving faster than ever. Competitors are appearing with entirely new business models. The ground is shifting – and this is a challenge for everyone on the leadership team.
Operations, in its broadest definition could be the secret ingredient in helping companies win in this environment – if operations itself was better aligned to business strategy and across functional domains. Too often a change in one place hurts performance in another. For example, think of what happens when a company takes steps to reduce inventory or customer service staffing.Too often, customers see empty shelves or they experience poor delivery reliability or frustratingly slow response times. Said another way: there are limits when each function improves its own performance without thinking of cross-functional trade-offs first.
To find out how companies are solving the operations puzzle, we talked with executives who make choices every single day on how to make the company strategy a reality. Most don’t think of operations as mere utilities. Instead, they see new opportunities to drive their company’s destiny like never before. The best companies are cultivating a coordinated set of operational strengths based on what customers want and what fits with company strategy. We think this is the direction operations leaders are headed – and after surveying more than 1,200 COOs and operations executives about their priorities for PwC's 2015 Global Operations Survey, we've been seeing the evolution in action. We've also held in-depth discussions with leaders across a range of industries with unique insights to offer on the subject.
Our survey finds that:
- Knowing what customers value is a real and persistent challenge for operations executives. And this makes it difficult to set priorities, manage costs in a strategic way, and choose the right trade-offs when necessary.
- Companies plan to do more than just improve existing processes. Instead they’re looking for ways to transform their businesses without letting day-to-day performance slip.
- Operations itself is being reimagined. Leading companies realise they need a model that aligns operations with strategy and helps them stay resilient in the face of significant change.
- Strategically aligned companies are more confident and more likely to focus on a few differentiating capabilities that drive competitive advantage. We agree that this is the right approach. When taking this path, there are two dimensions to consider: what customers value in your chosen markets and your company’s existing operational strengths.
Knowing what customers value is a real and persistent challenge for operations executives
When customer behaviours change, everyone in the organisation is affected. A striking three out of five operations leaders (61%) expect that changes in customer behaviours will become a disruptive factor for their industry in the next five years. Nearly the same number (63%) say that understanding what customers value is already a challenge for their own company operations. And few (25%) feel very confident that their operations are designed to give their customers value and a distinctive experience, now or even three years from now.
What the leaders do
It's easier when you design operations around your customers. That way, your operations teams can make appropriate trade-offs and more timely decisions when inevitable changes come. At Schneider Electric, for example, a global specialist in energy management, the executive team has recognised five customer-dominant buying behaviours. These behaviours serve as the foundation for tailoring a supply chain of 45,000 suppliers and 90,000 staff who run the company’s factories, distribution centres, and logistic networks on a daily basis.
The goal is to create an environment where keeping up with the customer doesn’t become an overwhelming challenge. Without this type of leadership, we often see operations stretched too thin. When one team tries to innovate, they come in direct conflict with an operational assignment to cut costs – or they create some new complexity that's harder to manage. Negotiating trade-offs can slow everyone down. In fact, two-thirds of our respondents (61%) say it's a challenge for operations to change direction when markets, customer needs, or enterprise strategies change.
Companies plan to do more than just improve existing processes
Today, nearly every aspect of operational excellence can be copied, and it often becomes industry standard. A majority of global companies (58%) recognise this and say that continuous improvement of existing processes doesn't drive their companies' operations. Instead, they balance day-to-day process improvement goals with longer-term efforts to transform what operations is and what it delivers.
For years, company leaders have asked functional managers to find ways to 'do more with less', and their teams have obliged. So product teams have enhanced feature sets, customer teams have improved service levels, and sourcing teams have cut costs and so on. But tensions have grown as customer expectations have changed. In fact, our respondents agree that working in silos – even hyperefficiently – isn't the answer.
So what has the greatest potential for helping the company reach its strategic goals? Three out of five (61%) say the solution is collaborating more across functions, paired with faster decision-making.
3 of 5 operations leaders believe cross-functional collaboration has the greatest potential for helping the company reach its strategic goals.
Unlocking the potential of operations
In fact, C-suites have been thinking of operations more broadly than the traditional view of sourcing, manufacturing, and supply chain, or, in the service world, front, middle, and back office. Across industries, 60% or more of our survey respondents now manage these functions as part of operations too: customer insights, marketing, sales, service and support, and new product and service development.
For those companies, there is a growing expectation that stepping away from traditional functional thinking will help unlock the potential of operations so that executives can work across organisational and geographical boundaries to solve enterprise-level problems.
But it takes more than a broader view of operations from the C-suite to sync up strategy across the company. And many companies admit they are not there. Only about a third (36%) of companies prioritise a few cross-functional capabilities at the company level and expect functional leaders to identify how they contribute to the mission. Most of the rest work in silos, with each function making its own decisions on which capabilities matter most (55%).
Operations itself is being reimagined
Leading companies realise they need a model so they can stay resilient in the face of significant change. For many, this means focusing on a few closely linked capabilities – or what one company calls an ‘architecture for transformation’. With this core in place, they can keep pace with changing customer expectations and manage the inevitable trade-offs when they arise.
What is a capability? It’s the ability to reliably and consistently deliver a specified outcome, relevant to your business. Each is ensured through the right combination of processes, tools, knowledge, skills, and organisation, all focused on meeting the desired result. The most important capabilities are distinctive: each of them represents an extraordinary competence that few others can master.
Jabil Circuit, one of the world's largest manufacturing solutions providers, shows us what such a model might look like. This integrator adds value by connecting unconventional partners within the business ecosystem and guides customers through every step of the product development process.
The company is building a focused system of mutually reinforcing capabilities. And it’s the power of these capabilities, working in concert that is intended to make working with Jabil unique. Here’s a look at those capabilities and the operational elements that support them.
A capabilities system: Jabil Circuit
What makes up the company’s differentiating capabilities?
Jabil has been developing four interlocking capabilities that work together as a system:
First-time design: Jabil imagines innovative commercial uses for new technologies and cross-pollinates ideas that can be used in multiple sectors.
An extended enterprise: A high-degree of collaboration with both customers and suppliers is in place to promote quality, consistency, and speed to market.
Highly predictive and responsive supply chain: Predicting opportunities and issues before they happen can save customers time and money.
Advanced IP protection and knowledge sharing: Built-in protections and assurances give customers peace of mind.
How is the company building and strengthening their capabilities?
When we look at the ‘how’ we notice that capabilities may require a cross-functional approach. Here are some examples of how this works in practice:
Elements of first-time design
- A state of the art concept-to-prototype centre, Jabil’s Blue Sky Center, is a hub for the co-creation of new products and services
- Data and experience are combined to foresee the commercial applications of new technologies (e.g., flexible circuitry, smart fabrics, and optics miniaturisation)
- An in-house engineering team provides expertise for 13 different sectors
- Jabil has made advanced technologies, particularly those with multiple uses, a cornerstone of their acquisition/investment strategy
Elements of an extended enterprise
- The company shares risk and reward with OEMs and suppliers
- Design teams cross-pollinate uses for new technologies and connect unconventional partners
- Jabil commits to extensive B2B connectivity and relationship building
- It locates assets where customers gain an advantage in areas such as labour cost, talent or regulatory compliance
Elements of a highly responsive and predictive supply chain
- Jabil runs an effective global command centre/control tower platform for real-time transparency 24x7x365
- It can flex the global supply chain up or down based on need
- It can anticipate supply and demand using advanced analytics and proactively address concerns before they become issues for customers
Elements of advanced IP protection and knowledge sharing
- Customers work with a dedicated ‘workcell’, a cross-functional team dedicated to them
- Jabil lives by a ‘no headlines’ policy, reducing risks of information leaks
- Customers receive supply assurance, helping them keep delivery on track
Of course, this isn't the only way to win as a manufacturing solutions provider. Other companies will choose and define what to emphasize according to their own strategies. Defining the capabilities you’ll need to win, though, is essential.
Strategically aligned companies are more confident and more likely to focus on a few differentiating capabilities that drive competitive advantage
Now is the time to ask, can your team make operational decisions on a small, yet focused set of priorities for how you plan to play and win in your company’s chosen markets? Of the companies we surveyed, 42% say they plan to take this path by 2018. If successful, they will significantly alter the competitive field and challenge even the most dominant market players.
We tested this idea by looking at the more strategically aligned companies in our survey, which is about 15% of our survey pool. A few things set them far apart from their peers. First, they're far more likely than everyone else to focus on building a few differentiating capabilities to drive a competitive advantage (51% vs. 29%). They're also more confident they'll achieve a broad set of performance objectives: achieving revenue and cost targets, driving strategy, providing a distinctive customer experience, and adapting to change.
Translate the strategic into the everyday
Every company requires a unique combination of capabilities to differentiate itself. When your operations teams have clarity on what these are, it’s easier to blueprint, build, and scale them across the enterprise. You can more readily spot where disconnects occur or priorities are misalinged.
For a given company, there are only a few capabilities that make that company unique. Others have become industry norms but aren't differentiators. Some are basic and can be managed for efficiency – and the rest don't matter a whole lot (see table).
Questions to consider
When creating your own company blueprint, you'll start with a clear-eyed assessment of the business opportunities, starting from the customer and working backward. And you’ll need the same review of your true operational strengths. It all leads to one question: how do we intend to play and win in our chosen market(s)? Then, it’s time to think about choices that will define how your company operates:
What makes your company different? Which capabilities will define your company in the eyes of your customers? Asking this question helps you make clear choices about what will set you apart.
Are you offering the right things? Are your existing products and services still coherent with your strategic plan? Are you getting distracted by legacy offerings that no longer fit? Incoherence is a signal that your operations may be stretched beyond what your company can do well.
Are you doing the right things? What operational choices do you need to make to strengthen your differentiated capabilities? And sometimes hardest of all: what will you stop doing to support investment in what really matters?
From there, you may want to do even more. In our work, we’ve seen this type of assessment lead companies to do other things, such as:
- Make cross-functional development of future leaders a much higher priority.
- Refine the capital allocation process to reflect priorities that are company-wide, and not merely functional.
- Work more closely with select value chain partners. This may include tighter IT and system connections, to let everyone make faster decisions and work together more effectively.
- Simplify operations through ongoing, ruthless reviews of requirements.
- Review, prioritise and rationalise the existing portfolio of operations improvement efforts. Doing everything a little better is less valuable than doing the most important things a lot better.
- Update the operating model to leverage global scale or emphasise a local presence, depending on whether standards or customisation matter more.
The new operations: value for the long term
Today, a majority of operations executives are focused on transformative change and new ways of creating value. It’s a truly exciting time to be in operations. But without the proper framework for deciding what needs to be done – and without collaboration across operations to do the work – some companies may find that they won't be able to take advantage of all the opportunities in front of them.
Whether you're a CEO or the operational executive in charge of a geographic P&L, you need your teams to work on what matters most. This means framing your operational choices to continually strengthen and reinforce what makes your company unique. When you do this, it will be hard for anyone else to copy your customers' experience. This is hard work: it requires real honesty about strengths, and a willingness to come together, even if this means doing very different things, and doing them very differently.
The good news? More companies are getting experience with a capabilities-driven strategy, and it’s possible to fast-track your operational decisions. For operations leaders, it's a chance to drive your companies' destiny like never before. And for companies, it's the path to sustainable advantages, even in the face of change.
|Creating your capabilities profile
Every company relies on a different set of capabilities, based on its strategic intent or ‘way to play’.
|Differentiating capabilities or ‘right to win’||
These make a company what it is
An organisation's strategy depends on these capabilities. They work together to deliver operational excellence or the experience that customers value.
|Competitive necessities or ‘right to compete’||
These are required in a given sector
Industry members generally share these capabilities. In banking, for example, cybersecurity is a standard expectation. On some level, all players must do this.
|Basic business capabilities or ‘right to play’||
These just ‘keep the lights on’
These capabilities are often utilities. In most firms, for example, tax reporting or facilities maintenance are required, but not valued or noticed by most customers.
|All other activity||
These may no longer contribute value
These capabilities may not be relevant to current strategy. They might be linked to outdated offerings, or regulatory compliance that no longer applies.
|Source: Adapted from strategy+business, ‘Is your Company Fit for Growth?‘ May 2012.|
Create your own custom charts
Perspectives from operations leaders
On organising by how clients see the world:
Citi touches clients nearly ten billion times a year. And when we acquire new clients, those clients are acquired through our Operations team. My instinct is that there’s going to be a big pivot where operationally, we think about running our business by client journey and begin to organise ourselves against them. You can imagine that we may even align technology that way. So instead of having a technology infrastructure aligned to cards or the retail bank or the operational teams, we would have an organisation aligned to how clients see the world.
Head of Operations for the Global Consumer Bank at Citi
On operations that make sense for the whole company:
Having the right architecture for business transformation means you know how to make choices and decide what your priorities are. Today we see five customer-dominant buying behaviours that make sense for the whole company. They serve as a foundation for how we plan to tailor our supply chain of 45,000 suppliers and the 90,000 who run our factories, distribution centres, and logistic networks. We plan to do even more for our customers by improving speed and responsiveness, employing the best digital tools, and enhancing our single integrated operating plan (SIOP), network optimisation, and global footprint.
Chief Supply Chain Officer and Executive Vice President, Global Supply Chain, Schneider Electric
On working across functions to execute against customer expectations:
The holiday season is our time to shine in the toy business because that’s when customers’ expectations of us are the highest. From September through the end of December, we roll up our sleeves and we’re very hands-on and operational as we strive to ensure that customers can shop with us however, whenever and where they want. In some ways, the volume during the holiday season makes the operational challenges very different for us than for other retailers.
What we must deliver is a really smooth, integrated operation that allows us to compete on the dimensions our customers care about. Doing this requires planning and executing arm-in-arm across not only traditional operations functions, but also marketing and merchandising. And, the need for coordination only increases with greater channel diversification.
Senior Vice President & Chief Supply Chain Officer, Toys “R” Us, Inc.
On leveraging expertise across the company:
More and more we’re not thinking about our organisation in discrete independent functional silos, but as a very, very connected ecosystem that leverages big data, leverages analytics, leverages unstructured data and pieces together information in ways that are more powerful for our customers and our employees. Leveraging expertise from different areas of the company has certainly become more and more important for us in terms of our continued migration to be a solution provider. If you think about the level of innovation that is taking place today, how much more quickly that innovation is taking place, I think it’s true for the whole industry.
William D. Muir, Jr.
Chief Operating Officer, Jabil Circuit Inc.
On the value of a one company operating strategy:
In our view, the winners of the next decade are going to be value chain integrators, because they are going to be outstanding managers of complexity and innovation. With our one company operating strategy we use complexity to our advantage. We reduce complexity where it makes sense, but we actually increase complexity where we think our customers benefit.
President Information Services & Supply Chain Operations, BASF
On operations capabilities:
To achieve our mission, several capabilities need to work together: how we drive innovation, how we select partners and acquisition targets, and how we deliver through our supply chain. Last year, we launched more than 200 new products around the world. Between research and development, engineering, supply chain, and production, we work to streamline our processes to launch products in quick cycles. The second part is our strategy for expansion. In 2014, we either acquired or increased the company’s equity stake in a total of 12 companies on five continents, including Transitions which was the largest ever in the history of Essilor. So we’re designing our network of labs, manufacturing facilities and suppliers to ensure proximity to customers.
Vice President of Global Supply Chain and Rx Strategy, Essilor International SA
On the importance of an agile supply chain:
From an operations point of view, it is key to have an agile, very flexible supply chain that can adapt to changes very quickly. Next to OTIF, cost and risk management is very key for us but it is changing. For example, ten years ago the labour expenditure for finishing and packaging cigars was 80%, and 20% was for labelling including health warnings and taxes. But today those proportions are switched. As part of this, we’ve had to become very good at knowing when to time our tax payments and assuring compliance at all stages of the supply chain.
Senior Vice President, Global Operations, Oettinger Davidoff AG
On integration with partnering organisations:
Our distinctive edge at MD Anderson is that we have a sole focus. So, unlike many other providers, we have one very clear priority and that’s oncology. Specific to oncology there are five large value propositions that apply across the cancer care continuum ranging from business, clinical, research, infrastructure, and innovation. These value propositions are the basis for how we consider potential partners on a global scale. It’s not enough to have a loose alignment, MD Anderson must develop true integration of practices across its partner network.
Vice President of Business Development, MD Anderson Cancer Center